Everton vs West Ham United: A Mid-Table Melee at Hill Dickinson Stadium
As the football calendar presents another intriguing fixture, Everton and West Ham United prepare to lock horns on the neutral ground of the Hill Dickinson Stadium this evening. With both teams navigating the early pressures of the 2025/2026 season, this encounter holds significant weight, promising a fierce battle for crucial points. Will the Toffees’ recent resurgence continue, or can the Hammers find their rhythm away from home? The stage is set for a professional, yet passionate, clash under the lights.
Head-to-Head History
The rivalry between Everton and West Ham United spans over a century, with a rich history of competitive encounters. Across all competitions, these two sides have met a grand total of 153 times. Everton holds a clear advantage in the overall head-to-head record, boasting 75 victories compared to West Ham’s 45, with 33 matches ending in a draw.
Focusing on the Premier League era, the Toffees have also largely dominated. In 58 Premier League meetings, Everton has secured 29 wins, while West Ham has managed 14, with 15 draws recorded. Historically, Everton’s biggest triumph over the Hammers was a resounding 7-0 victory in October 1927, while West Ham’s largest winning margin against Everton has been 4-0 on two occasions.
Recent form suggests a more balanced contest, however. The last five meetings across all competitions paint a picture of fluctuating fortunes:
- 30 July 2025: West Ham United 2-1 Everton (Premier League Summer Series)
- 15 March 2025: Everton 1-1 West Ham United (Premier League)
- 09 November 2024: West Ham United 0-0 Everton (Premier League)
- 02 March 2024: Everton 1-3 West Ham United (Premier League)
- 29 October 2023: West Ham United 0-1 Everton (Premier League)
These recent results highlight a period where West Ham has shown an improved ability to challenge Everton, securing two wins, two draws, and just one loss in their last five encounters.
Current Form & Team News (Hypothetical for Match Day)
As this match takes place today, September 29, 2025, we present a hypothetical snapshot of both teams’ recent form and squad availability:
Everton
Everton enters this fixture in a cautiously optimistic mood, having shown flashes of their potential amidst some inconsistency. Their last five competitive matches have yielded a mixed bag of results: (W-D-L-W-L).
- (W) vs. AFC Bournemouth (H) – 2-0
- (D) vs. Fulham (A) – 1-1
- (L) vs. Manchester United (H) – 0-3
- (W) vs. Burnley (A) – 2-1
- (L) vs. Chelsea (H) – 1-0
The Toffees have been boosted by the return of key midfielder Amadou Onana from a hamstring injury, which will significantly bolster their central control. Young winger Dwight McNeil has also been in scintillating form, contributing crucial assists and goals. However, manager Sean Dyche will be without central defender James Tarkowski, who serves a one-match suspension after accumulating five yellow cards. A minor doubt hangs over the fitness of full-back Vitaliy Mykolenko, who picked up a knock in training, potentially paving the way for Ashley Young to start.
West Ham United
West Ham United, on the other hand, has endured a more challenging run recently, struggling to find a consistent winning formula. Their last five results read: (L-W-L-L-D).
- (L) vs. Tottenham Hotspur (A) – 2-1
- (W) vs. Luton Town (H) – 3-1
- (L) vs. Newcastle United (H) – 0-1
- (L) vs. Aston Villa (A) – 2-0
- (D) vs. Nottingham Forest (H) – 2-2
David Moyes’ side has been plagued by defensive lapses and a lack of cutting edge in front of goal. Striker Michail Antonio is still recovering from a knee injury and remains unavailable. There are also concerns over the fitness of Edson Álvarez, who is nursing a slight muscle strain, which could force a reshuffle in midfield. Lucas Paquetá, despite the team’s struggles, has remained a creative spark and will be crucial to unlocking Everton’s defence. The Hammers will be hoping Jarrod Bowen can rediscover his scoring touch to provide the necessary firepower.
Tactical Preview
Given the strengths and weaknesses of both sides, this match is likely to be a cagey affair, particularly in midfield. Everton, under Sean Dyche, will likely opt for a robust 4-4-2 formation, focusing on defensive solidity, pressing high, and direct attacks. The return of Onana will be vital in winning aerial duels and disrupting West Ham’s rhythm in the center of the park. Expect their wide players to track back diligently and look for quick transitions to feed Dominic Calvert-Lewin upfront.
West Ham United, typically favouring a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 under David Moyes, will aim to control possession and exploit the flanks through creative wing play from players like Bowen and Kudus. The potential absence of Álvarez could force Flynn Downes or James Ward-Prowse into a deeper, more defensive role, impacting their ability to link with the attack. The midfield battle will be pivotal, with the team that dominates the central areas likely to dictate the tempo. West Ham’s defensive vulnerabilities, particularly against pace, could be an area Everton looks to exploit.
The Hill Dickinson Stadium, a neutral venue, removes any traditional home advantage, potentially leading to a more open game as both teams adjust to unfamiliar surroundings. As for weather, a cool, dry evening is expected, which should allow for a fast-paced game without significant pitch or atmospheric impediments.
